The Fair Elections Act is an attack on Canadian Democracy

I just emailed the PMO again on the proposed Fair Elections Act, but forgot to save my text. In a nutshell, I am astonished to read of the government’s attacking of Sheila Fraser, and appalled (but not surprised) to see its attacks on Marc Mayrand. I agree with Sheila Fraser and Andrew Coyne that the so-called Fair Elections Act is an attack on democracy.

I believe that somehow while in office, Stephen Harper has somehow lost his way. He has become the very thing he criticized so well when we was in Opposition. The corruption, lack of oversight, use of omnibus bills and fast-track procedures, together with these attacks on the fundamental principles of democracy–it’s all dangerously alarming and very far from what good governance should be.

Mr. Harper was opposed and vilified early on, when he shouldn’t have been. The consequence of this is that now, when his government should be vilified and vigorously opposed, people may be apathetic. If the next election is fair at all–and that is a significant if, given the proposed legislation–I hope the Canadian public turns his party out of office.

I have often written that I have never considered our Prime Minister to be Darth Vader. With the Fair Elections Act, I now believe him to be much worse: he’s Chancellor Palpatine. If you don’t want a Star Wars metaphor, I’ll give you a real-world one: he’s got far more in common with the early Vladimir Putin than he should have.

Posted in Federal Politics, Politics | Comments Off

Cherry Blossoms on W. 22nd Ave. in Vancouver, BC

Cherry Blossoms 2014 on West 22nd Ave. in Vancouver 4

Posted in BC & Vancouver, Gardens, Flowers, and Plants, Photoblogging | Comments Off

Cherry Blossoms budding on W. 22nd Ave. in Vancouver, BC

Cherry Blossoms 2014 on West 22nd Ave in Vancouver 5b

Posted in BC & Vancouver, Gardens, Flowers, and Plants, Photoblogging | Comments Off

Cherry Blossom Cluster on West 22nd Ave. in Vancouver, BC

Cherry Blossom cluster March 2014

Little pink fingers
Reach for the white bright sun with
Sticky sugar skin

The second week of my annual hanami took place last Sunday, when I went with my family to Burrard Station in downtown Vancouver, and then to West 16th between Granville and Arbutus, and then after to West 22nd (west of Arbutus) to take in the most gorgeous and amazing cherry blossoms. My pictures really don’t do them justice, but I’ll be posting a few here in the next few days.

Posted in BC & Vancouver, Gardens, Flowers, and Plants, Photoblogging | Comments Off

Elections Act follow-up: a form-letter from the PMO, and my response

My previous post dealt with the Elections Act and why the government should let its most contentious bill die a quick death. Shortly after writing my letter, I received this response:

On behalf of the Prime Minister, thank you for your correspondence regarding the Fair Elections Act. We appreciated the opportunity to review your comments.

Our Government is strongly committed to reforming Canada’s elections laws to uphold the integrity of the voting system. The Fair Elections Act will ensure our laws are tough, clear and easy to follow. These necessary changes will be implemented prior to the next federal election.

This legislation is the result of consultations with Elections Canada, parliamentarians, think tanks and other relevant groups. It will implement 38 of the Chief Electoral Officer’s past recommendations. Most importantly, it will make it much more difficult to violate elections laws and put the focus back on honest people exercising their franchise in our democracy.

Some of the highlights of the Fair Elections Act include:

- Protecting voters from rogue calls with a mandatory public registry for mass calling, prison time for impersonating elections officials, and increased penalties.

- Giving more independence to the Commissioner of Canada Elections, which is the enforcement wing of Elections Canada, allowing them control over their staff and investigations, empowering them to seek tougher penalties for existing electoral offences, and providing more than a dozen new offences to combat big money, rogue calls and fraudulent voting.

- Cracking down on voter fraud.

- Making the rules for elections clear, predictable and easier to follow.

- Banning the use of loans that are used to evade donation rules.

- Repealing the ban on reporting election results as they become known across the country, upholding free speech.

- Providing better customer service to voters, and establishing an extra day of polling.

We have noted your specific concerns with respect to vouching procedure changes. These reforms are necessary in light of Elections Canada studies that demonstrate mass irregularities in vouching and high rates of inaccuracy on Voter Information Cards. While vouching will no longer be permitted, voters will have 39 authorized ID forms to utilize when proving identity and residence. Elections Canada will communicate clearly to voters what form of ID are accepted before they head to the polls.

For more detailed information on each of these measures, we invite you to visit the following link:

Once again, thank you for taking the time to share your views on this important legislation.


[name redacted]
Assistant to the Prime Minister

Here is my response:

Dear Honorable Prime Minister (and [name redacted]),

I would like to thank you for your office’s response to my original letter on the subject of the proposed Elections Act. I am grateful that you took the time to write it and to note one of my two primary criticisms of this bill (vouching).

I remain very much dismayed, though, by the willful blindness, if not outright deceitfulness demonstrated by your government in communicating with both me specifically and the public in regards to some aspects of this bill, particularly as regards the matter of vouching. For instance, your office has written:

“These reforms are necessary in light of Elections Canada studies that demonstrate mass irregularities in vouching and high rates of inaccuracy on Voter Information Cards.”

Unfortunately, Elections Canada has not said anything about “mass irregularities in vouching.” Indeed, the author of the report cited by Minister Poilievre in this regard has specifically said of the Minister: “I think any fair-minded person who reads that report would come to the conclusion that he has not been fair in his assessment of my findings” (CBC News, “Pierre Poilievre ‘selectively’ reading election report, author says“). Furthermore, the Globe and Mail has noted how the Government is grossly misrepresenting the positions of several experts (“Fair Elections Act: If evidence voted, this bill would die“). There was no “mass irregularity” at all connected with vouching in the last election. Mr. Prime Minister, you are entitled to your own opinions, but you are not entitled to your own facts.

Furthermore, your office did not at all acknowledge my other point regarding the proposed Elections Act: namely, how it greatly weakens both the mandate and the power of Elections Canada. The Elections Act is adamantly opposed by the non-partisan head of Elections Canada and by pretty much everyone connected with the administration of our elections. It is supported only by your own political party. Why?

Finally, I now see that you are trying to rush this bill through not only the House of Commons, but the Senate, too. This (together with your singularly poor choice of Senators) shows that you do not appreciate the value of the upper chamber as one of “sober second thought.” In forcing this bill too quickly through the Senate, you are denying Canadians what we are paying for: a governmental body that is less hyper-partisan and more careful in its examination of proposed laws than the House of Commons.

I believe that the pursuit of knocking off as many as half a million potential unfriendly votes has clouded your judgment and your ethics–and I say this as someone who does not believe you are the Parliamentary equivalent of Darth Vader. (For example, I have noted before your steady hand at the helm of our economy during the recent global economic crisis.) But much of what you are doing with this bill is very wrong. Please put this bill to rest.

Thank you for your consideration.

Posted in Federal Politics, Politics | Comments Off

Letter to the Prime Minister on the proposed Fair Elections Act

The following is the full version of a letter I have just sent the Prime Minister:

Dear Hon. Prime Minister:

I am writing in regards to the proposed Fair Elections Act. Mr. Prime Minister, after reading extensive coverage of this proposed Act, including an excellent editorial in the Globe and Mail (“Criticism of Elections Act is legitimate, and should not be brushed off“), I am horrified by your government’s proposed legislation. The Fair Elections Act is nothing short of an attack on the practice of democracy and the primacy of the rule of law in Canada, for two reasons.

First, the bill removes the ability of many citizens to vote and ends the practice of “vouching.” I can understand how one would want voters to be intelligent and motivated enough to get proper ID in order to choose the next government, but our democracy does not specify intelligence levels necessary to vote; it is enough to be a Canadian citizen of age 19 or above. The enfrachisement of all Canadian adults is foundational to our democracy. Unfortunately, there are many cases where citizens may not have the required documents to prove who they say they are, for example, many elderly people in old folks’ homes, university students staying in other cities, First Nations on reserves, and many homeless people. It is well-known that none of these groups (with the possible exception of the elderly) are Conservative voters. Removing the rights of these voters to vote is nothing but a transparently selfish power-grab that benefits only your own political party at the expense of removing many Canadian citizens’ right to vote.

Second, the bill greatly weakens Elections Canada. The bill removes Elections Canada’s authority to encourage voting (e.g. among the young), allows incumbent parties to choose election officials, and prohibits Elections Canada from communicating with the public about its investigations into electoral skulduggery. Again, all this chiefly benefits your own party while tearing down a useful Canadian institution that guarantees the fairness of our elections.

Mr. Prime Minister, it is not only the right to vote that makes a real, functioning democracy–it is also the presence of institutions that are connected with the rule of law. Elections Canada is an essential, reliable, and correctly non-partisan institution that is necessary to our survival as a democracy. Political parties are already allowed scrutineers in the electoral process–but why give incumbents power over the election itself as your bill would do?

In short, Mr. Prime Minister, you have attacked the very state of democracy and the rule of law in Canada with this bill, and for no justifiable reasons whatsoever other than the benefit of our own political party. You should do the “right” thing and “kill this bill” (as a different Globe and Mail article put it) now.

Thank you for your consideration.

Posted in Federal Politics, Politics | Comments Off

The blossoms are coming, the blossoms are coming!

Cherry Blossoms at Burrard Station March 2014

A few days ago I went to Burrard Station, where I managed to somehow fail to take a single good picture. Despite this setback, I’m happy: Cherry Blossom time is my favourite time of year, and it’s only going to get better as the trees continue to blossom. I’ll need to try harder to get some better pictures, though.

Posted in BC & Vancouver, Gardens, Flowers, and Plants, Photoblogging | Comments Off

Vancouver Skyline from North Vancouver

Vancouver skyline from North Vancouver

Posted in Photoblogging | Comments Off

Chiba Garden in North Vancouver

Chiba Garden Gate

A few days ago I drove all the way to North Vancouver to see Chiba Garden, a very small Japanese-inspired garden in Waterfront Park. This is probably the first garden I have been to in a very long time that felt so ill-kept that I found the experience of visiting it a disappointment. It’s obvious that there are people sleeping there at night, and there were numerous beer cans and pieces of litter on the ground, as well as a carelessly-left hose. The garden has an unkempt, overgrown feel. I think having worked so close to the majestic Nitobe Garden at UBC spoiled me.

What follows are a few more pictures of Chiba Garden; I wasn’t particularly happy with any of them, but here they are anyway.

Chiba Garden gate 2

Stone lantern and trees in Chiba Garden in North Vancouver, BC

Chiba garden fence and trees

The thought occurs to me that I may have been too rushed and too distracted by the litter; after all, the garden’s small size made it easy to underestimate it. But in Japan, the miniature and compact can be celebrated. I should probably get back there at some point to try to take it in again, but I do hope that North Vancouver can maintain the garden better.

Posted in BC & Vancouver, Gardens, Flowers, and Plants, Photoblogging | Comments Off


Eating and
Arriving and
Receding in

I wrote the above a number of days ago while feeling particularly gloomy. I’m just posting it now, though oddly enough I feel better.

Posted in Original Poems | Comments Off